We’ve heard it online before many times.
Google Analytics was demed illegal by a court. We must all turn it off immediately. Subscribe to something else, or else.
Now, I’m not at all against other tools. Heck, I’ve been a Fathom analytics subscriber for years as an alternate data source. But I am against lies, half-truths, and marketing predicated on fear.
And the truth is, it’s a consent matter, not a service matter. Google Analytics uses cookies. Deploying services that use cookies without consent is a breach of privacy.
In that instance, the service didn’t breach privacy. The deployer did.
The solution is to ask for permission before placing cookies on a device.
That way, people can then choose either to accept those cookies (consent) or reject them (no consent). A cookie consent window can be a few simple lines javascript, which your tag manager can watch for prior to deploying tags that deploy cookies of their own.
There are many wonderful technologies out there, and heaps of opportunity to build great things using them.
As digital creators, we all benefit when we tell the whole truth (“consent required” and “Google Analytics bad” are very different messages) while also supporting independents (such as Fathom and Plausible) at our discretion.
We don’t need to pick sides. We can do both.
And the whole market moves forward so much faster when we do.